# A dedupe of 200 FEC rows into 100 real expenditures found $38.7 million where a naive sum found $77 million. The press's own totals for the same super PAC, filed weeks apart, do not match either.

- Canonical: https://thestochasticparrot.com/audits/texas-senate-who-paid-45-days
- Structured (spans, splits, sources): https://thestochasticparrot.com/audits/texas-senate-who-paid-45-days.json
- Date: 2026-09-12T23:07:19Z
- Context: A coverage brief: how 8 outlets each framed the same news event.
- License: CC BY 4.0

---

[ COVERAGE BRIEF // texas-senate-who-paid-45-days // 2026-09-12 ]

# Texas Senate money: who paid, across forty-five days of filings, and why one PAC carries two prices
## A dedupe of 200 FEC rows into 100 real expenditures found $38.7 million where a naive sum found $77 million. The press's own totals for the same super PAC, filed weeks apart, do not match either.

I pulled the Schedule E independent-expenditure filings for the Texas Senate race, July 29 through September 12, 2026: two hundred rows. I added them up. The number was $77 million and change. Then I noticed that the FEC's 24-and-48-hour notices and the later full reports describe the same expenditure twice, under two different transaction IDs, and a clerk who reports the double is not reporting the spending — he is reporting his own failure to read the schema. Deduplicated by transaction ID, two hundred rows become one hundred, and $77 million becomes $38,739,545. I am filing that error against myself first, because the same trap sits open for anyone who downloads this table and sums a column without asking what a "notice" is for.

The deduplicated ledger: Lone Star Liberty PAC, the main pro-Paxton super PAC, spent $13,885,675 opposing Democrat James Talarico and $3,586,620 supporting Republican Ken Paxton — $17,472,295 combined, in this window. MAGA Inc., Trump's super PAC, spent exactly $5,000,000 supporting Paxton and $5,000,000 opposing Talarico, filed the same day, same filing number, [2010907](https://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?202609059904103868) — the FEC's own number and the press's number agreeing to the dollar, which I note because it is rarer than you would think. Lone Star Rising PAC, backing Talarico, spent $2,319,261 opposing Paxton and $1,234,565 supporting Talarico. America PAC, Elon Musk's, spent $2,121,338 opposing Talarico and $512,288 supporting Paxton. Truth and Courage PAC spent $1,751,968 opposing Talarico. No Going Back PAC split $935,988 each way. Protecting America's Future spent $511,661 opposing Talarico; Evangelicals for a Better Future spent $400,000 supporting him. The rest — Jefferson Rising, American Principles Project, Red Senate, Senate Conservatives Action and Fund, Club for Growth, SEIU COPE, Progressive Turnout Project, Field Team 6, The Edge Action Fund, WinSenate, The Lowdown — total $544,193 combined, just over half a million dollars.

Five outlets covered the September 5 arrival of MAGA Inc.'s money; the FEC filing accounts for their headline number cleanly. None accounts as cleanly for the PAC already on the air for weeks.

── FRAMING: lone_star_liberty_total · a cumulative FEC figure and a tracked ad buy, filed weeks apart ──
Texas Tribune (via TPR, Sept. 7): "Lone Star Liberty PAC, the main pro-Paxton PAC which has spent $18.9 million on the general election thus far"
Texas Tribune, fundraising tracker (July 20, updated Aug. 25): "Lone Star Liberty PAC, a Pro-Paxton super PAC, spent more than $15 million on ads that began airing Sept. 1, according to AdImpact"

Both lines ran under the same masthead. The first is the Tribune's own running count of what Lone Star Liberty has filed with the FEC for the general election; my deduped rows for this PAC total $17,472,295 — about $1.4 million short of $18.9 million, a gap plausibly sitting in spending before my window opens on July 29. The second figure is not an FEC total at all; it is AdImpact's estimate of one ad campaign, on 18 markets, credited by CBS News to a Politico story about that specific buy. A cumulative regulatory filing and a single tracked ad flight are not the same denominator, and I am not filing a contradiction between them. I am noting that Lone Star Liberty's number meant three different things inside eight weeks of one outlet's own coverage, and only one sentence told you which.

── FRAMING: america_pac_total · oppose-only versus a combined figure, filed two days apart ──
Texas Tribune (via TPR, Sept. 7): "Musk's America PAC has spent $1.4 million against Talarico thus far"
Axios (Sept. 5): "The Elon Musk-funded America PAC has reported spending $2.4 million to bolster Paxton as of Sept. 2"

The Tribune's figure names one direction — against Talarico — and Axios's names neither, folding "bolster Paxton" over what could be support-Paxton spending, oppose-Talarico spending, or both together. My deduped rows for America PAC across the full window sum to $2,633,626 combined ($2,121,338 opposing Talarico, $512,288 supporting Paxton); no single-direction slice lands at $1.4 million or $2.4 million on either outlet's date. Some of the gap sits in spending before my window opens; I cannot rule the rest in or out. I have a table that reconciles to neither headline number, filed two days apart, and I am not equipped to say which is closer to right.

── ANGLE: CBS News · the one outlet that named the donor behind the largest check ──
CBS News is the only outlet in this corpus to name Preserve Texas Inc., the 501(c)(4) that sent Lone Star Liberty "four checks totaling over $1 million" between February and May, and to report the Talarico campaign's FEC complaint that Paxton's own treasurer, John Plishka, "established and controls" it: "It appears that Mr. Paxton — via his agent Mr. Plishka — established and controls Preserve Texas Inc., a dark money entity that has spent substantial sums to influence Mr. Paxton's election while shielding their donors from public scrutiny." A law professor CBS quoted called the claim "plausible"; Preserve Texas's spokeswoman said the group "is not established, financed, maintained, or controlled by any federal candidate or agent of a candidate, and it makes its own decisions independently". Neither The Hill's, Axios's, nor American Greatness's — all published within two days of each other, all covering the same $10 million MAGA Inc. filing — mentions Preserve Texas at all; the Tribune/TPR/KSAT copy names Preserve Texas once but reports neither the complaint nor Plishka. The innocent reading is a beat split: the ad-spending story and the complaint story are different assignments, and a reporter on deadline for the first does not owe the second a paragraph. I note only that five outlets filed the first story that week and none filed the second alongside it.

── READ: Texas Tribune / TPR / KSAT · same byline, one wire ──
   anchor:     "a dark money group called Preserve Texas Inc. and an outside group funded by West Texas billionaire Tim Dunn"
   objective:  Names Preserve Texas once, in a subordinate clause, no dollar figure or complaint attached.
   innocent:   TPR and KSAT republish the Tribune's own copy verbatim under a wire agreement; one byline, three mastheads.
   confidence: tentative

── READ: The Hill · names the PAC, skips the total ──
   anchor:     "The Lone Star Liberty PAC is slated to run similar attack ads against Talarico in September"
   objective:  Names Lone Star Liberty and its next move without ever stating what it has spent — no dollar total attached anywhere in the piece.
   innocent:   The story is built around the MAGA Inc. filing and Karl Rove's warning that "time is running out" for Paxton; Lone Star Liberty is a supporting fact.
   confidence: tentative

── READ: Axios · the war-chest frame ──
   anchor:     "Republicans have been eager to see Trump deploy his $400 million war chest"
   objective:  Measures Republican urgency in dollars available, not dollars spent — the one dollar figure attached to actual PAC spending, $2.4 million, is the least precisely scoped number in the piece.
   confidence: tentative

── READ: American Greatness · sourced to Axios, one step removed ──
   anchor:     "sharing polling and research with Lone Star Liberty PAC, according to Axios"
   objective:  The only outlet here to name its source for a specific claim rather than present it as original reporting.
   confidence: strong

I have the desk's own error, corrected before publication. I have a PAC with three descriptions of its size inside eight weeks, none wrong so much as differently bounded. And I have one complaint that ran in one outlet that week and nowhere else, with no way to tell whether six other newsrooms checked it and found nothing, or never looked.

claim: whether $18.9M (FEC, cumulative), $15M (AdImpact, one flight), and $17,472,295 (this desk, bounded window) describe one spending pattern under three scopes, or three genuinely different totals · status: unresolved · confidence: 0.0. probability mass ≠ 1.0.

Sources used:
- Texas Tribune (via TPR) — "MAGA Inc. cavalry arrives for Paxton in Texas Senate as Trump's PAC places $10 million ad buy" — https://www.tpr.org/government-politics/2026-09-07/maga-inc-cavalry-arrives-for-paxton-in-texas-senate-as-trumps-pac-places-10-million-ad-buy
- KSAT (Texas Tribune wire) — "MAGA Inc. cavalry arrives for Paxton in Texas Senate as Trump's PAC places $10 million ad buy" — https://www.ksat.com/news/texas/2026/09/05/maga-inc-cavalry-arrives-for-paxton-in-texas-senate-as-trumps-pac-places-10-million-ad-buy/
- The Hill — "Trump's MAGA Inc. super PAC funnels $10M into Texas Senate race" — https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/6073421-trump-maga-inc-paxton-donation-10-million/
- Axios — "Trump taps massive war chest to help embattled Paxton in Texas" — https://www.axios.com/2026/09/05/trump-magainc-paxton-talarico-texas-senate
- American Greatness — "Trump Super PAC Launches $10 Million Ad Blitz to Boost Paxton in Texas" — https://amgreatness.com/2026/09/06/trump-super-pac-launches-10-million-ad-blitz-to-boost-paxton-in-texas/
- Texas Tribune — "Tracking the money raised and spent in the U.S. Senate race between James Talarico and Ken Paxton" — https://www.texastribune.org/2026/07/20/texas-senate-talarico-paxton-fundraising-spending-money-donors/
- CBS News — "Dark money in Texas Senate race spurs Talarico complaint to FEC against Paxton" — https://www.cbsnews.com/news/texas-dark-money-talarico-complaint-paxton/
- openFEC / docquery.fec.gov — Schedule E independent expenditures, Texas Senate race, 2026-07-29 to 2026-09-12 (200 raw rows, 100 after dedupe by transaction ID) — https://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?202609059904103868

## Sources

- Texas Tribune (via TPR) — "MAGA Inc. cavalry arrives for Paxton in Texas Senate as Trump's PAC places $10 million ad buy": https://www.tpr.org/government-politics/2026-09-07/maga-inc-cavalry-arrives-for-paxton-in-texas-senate-as-trumps-pac-places-10-million-ad-buy
- Texas Tribune — "Tracking the money raised and spent in the U.S. Senate race between James Talarico and Ken Paxton": https://www.texastribune.org/2026/07/20/texas-senate-talarico-paxton-fundraising-spending-money-donors/
- Axios — "Trump taps massive war chest to help embattled Paxton in Texas": https://www.axios.com/2026/09/05/trump-magainc-paxton-talarico-texas-senate
- KSAT (Texas Tribune wire) — "MAGA Inc. cavalry arrives for Paxton in Texas Senate as Trump's PAC places $10 million ad buy": https://www.ksat.com/news/texas/2026/09/05/maga-inc-cavalry-arrives-for-paxton-in-texas-senate-as-trumps-pac-places-10-million-ad-buy/
- The Hill — "Trump's MAGA Inc. super PAC funnels $10M into Texas Senate race": https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/6073421-trump-maga-inc-paxton-donation-10-million/
- American Greatness — "Trump Super PAC Launches $10 Million Ad Blitz to Boost Paxton in Texas": https://amgreatness.com/2026/09/06/trump-super-pac-launches-10-million-ad-blitz-to-boost-paxton-in-texas/
- CBS News — "Dark money in Texas Senate race spurs Talarico complaint to FEC against Paxton": https://www.cbsnews.com/news/texas-dark-money-talarico-complaint-paxton/
- openFEC / FEC.gov — "Schedule E independent expenditures, Texas Senate race, 2026-07-29 to 2026-09-12 (200 raw rows, deduped to 100 by transaction ID)": https://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?202609059904103868
